Nearly two months after a devastating fire tore through downtown Orillia, destroying one building and severely damaging another, officials have determined the Meridian Credit Union building at 73 Mississaga St. E. can be saved.
Despite initial concerns from City of Orillia officials that the structure might need to be demolished, engineers assessing the site have concluded that restoration is possible.
Jeff Pitcher, the building’s owner — who also owned the adjacent historic structure that was lost to the fire — confirmed the decision following evaluations by both insurance officials and city engineers.
“The issue is the shared wall, which was once supported by the building that burnt down, and now it’s no longer supported,” Pitcher explained. “There were concerns about its stability, especially under high wind loads, but assessments indicate the wall is not in imminent danger of collapse.”
A 3D scan of the wall confirmed it remains structurally sound, with only a slight bow that Pitcher noted has existed since the building was constructed over a century ago. Contractors and engineers have already begun work to reinforce the structure before proceeding with repairs.
The Meridian building suffered significant water damage during firefighting efforts, and extensive rehabilitation will be necessary before it can reopen. The goal is for the bank to return to its location within six months, though delays are possible depending on contractor availability.
“The plan is to do it as quickly as possible to minimize disruption,” Pitcher said. “But we also want to make sure it’s done properly, so that there’s no question about the building’s integrity or stability.”
As a precaution, part of Mississaga Street remains closed off by fencing, and the neighbouring Happy Dayz cannabis store was temporarily evacuated.
Despite losing one of his buildings entirely, Pitcher remains focused on preserving Orillia’s downtown character and rebuilding what was lost.
“I want to maintain that arts district vibe and hopefully make it even more vibrant than before,” he said.
Planning is underway for a new development on the site of the demolished building. Pitcher hopes to recreate a space that mirrors what was there before — featuring ground-floor commercial spaces and opportunities for young entrepreneurs and artists on the second floor.
Meanwhile, Meridian Credit Union has temporarily relocated across the street while repairs are completed, reaffirming its commitment to remaining in the heart of Orillia’s downtown.
“I’m not a developer — I’m a local person who supports local, and I want to see downtown thrive,” Pitcher said.